Here is a space for our class to share comments about out-of-class readings and other current assignments.
Tuesday, October 25, 2011
ICB, "The Corner": Is Justice Served?
Is the trial of Dick and Perry a fair one? One might conclude that Capote did not believe this to be the case. He provides numerous details in "The Corner" that indicate he believes justice was not served ... at least not fairly. Cite one -- JUST ONE -- of these details and discuss it. Try to find something a classmate has not already discussed here.
ICB, "The Corner": Pity for Perry?
Aside from providing details that possibly suggest Dick and Perry's trial was an unfair one, how does Capote build sympathy for Perry? Excerpt a particular part of the text from "The Corner" in your response.
ICB, "The Corner": More Killers?
Why do you suspect Capote includes the stories of some of the other killers on death row alongside Dick and Perry? Is he simply being thorough or is there another motive here? Try to include an excerpt from the text in your response. (Read what others have said; try to add to the conversation rather than simply repeating what has been written previously.)
Tuesday, October 18, 2011
ICB, "The Answer": Making Connections
So now you know. If you have read "Answer," the third section of Capote's In Cold Blood, you have heard an account of how the Clutter murders occured. Now I'd like you to connect some dots. Isolate a detail from the account -- how things happened, why things happened the way they did -- and tie it back to details Capote provided us earlier in the novel (in this section or an earlier one). Why did Capote include this detail? Was he simply being thorough -- or did he feel it revealed something about the characters? Weigh in on the motives and/or feelinsg of our killers and/or our victims. Try not to duplicate earlier efforts by your classmates.
Friday, October 7, 2011
ICB, "Persons Unknown": Who Is Affected?
The title of the second section of Capote's In Cold Blood obviously refers to our killers, who are on the run and whose identities are unknown to the authorities and the townspeople of Holcomb. But it also refers to those residents of Holcomb. How have they been changed by the Clutters' deaths? Cite and discuss a specific excerpt from this section.
ICB, "Persons Unknown": Rashomon Effect
Rashomon is an old Japanese film in which one tragic event is told from four different perspectives, each belonging to a person involved in the tragedy. Each retelling provides the viewer new insights. Capote does something similar with the sections that begin on pages 107 and 110. Each recounts Perry and Dick making their way down a desert road, but one account is told from Perry's perspective, the other from Dick's. What does the scene and Capote's handling of it tell us about Perry and Dick's partnership? Are they alike or quite the opposite? Cite a specific detail from these pages, and if you feel your classmates have left you nothing original to discuss from this scene, turn elsewhere in "Persons Unknown" for material.
ICB, "Persons Unknown": Mitigating Evidence
We learn much about Perry's past in this section. Is there anything about his upbringing that serves as mitigating evidence to make your pity him? Think about the "In the Face of Death" article we read. In that, the author explained how Jeremy Gross's attorney supplied the jury with information about his client in hopes of preventing a death sentence. That attorney tried to make Jeremy seem more human, more worthy of sympathy. Does anything in Perry's past have the same effect? Select one detail (preferably something a classmate has not already discussed) and provide your insights.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)